The Ninth Circuit reversed Judge Patel's finding that the crime-fraud exception applied in the follow-on litigation to the Napster case. . . . . Judge Patel is being credited with being the catalyst for the firing of the US Attorney for San Francisco -- allegedly her second such trophy. . . . . Activists have charged that law firm diversity programs prompted by demand from corporate clients may run afoul of anti-discrimination laws. . . . . Defense lawyers are claiming that the resolution of the HP pretexting matters are a huge victory for them and an embarrassment for state prosecutors (principally, former state AG Bill Lockyer, who personally promoted the prosecutions in the press). . . . . The Duane Morris law firm has been un-disqualified in the highly publicized matter concerning McKesson.